The Basics Of Progressive Vs State Farm Car Insurance
State Farm and Progressive are two of the biggest auto insurance companies in the U.S. In terms of direct premiums, State Farm was the top company in private passenger auto insurance for 2021 with 16% of the market share. Progressive ranked third with a share of 13.8%. For commercial auto insurance, Progressive ranked first. Both companies are financially stable. State Farm has earned the highest possible A++ rating from A.M. Best and an AA rating from Standard and Poor . Progressive, meanwhile, has earned an A+ rating from A.M. Best and an AA from S& P.
Both companies have long histories in the insurance industry, too. Founded in 1922 to provide affordable auto insurance to farmers in Illinois, State Farm can claim 100 years of experience. Progressive was established in Cleveland, Ohio, 15 years later. Today, drivers can obtain not only auto insurance from these companies but also insurance for their homes, property, businesses, pets, and more. Both companies have a presence in every state plus D.C., but State Farm is no longer writing new car insurance policies in Massachusetts and Rhode Island.
To decide between Progressive vs. State Farm car insurance, consider four key factors:
- Coverage options
- Roadside assistance
- Ride-share insurance
Progressive Vs State Farm: Online And Mobile Experience Comparison
State Farm and Progressive both have an intuitive online user experience. Their websites are easy to navigate, you can get instant quotes and both companies provide helpful tools and resources. Progressive and State Farm also have online claim submission systems, which makes it easy to file new claims and check the status of existing claims without calling an agent.
In addition, State Farm and Progressive each have a mobile app. Both companies offer an app-based safe driver telematics rewards program, as well as a traditional mobile app where you can make payments, get your ID cards and more. Here is a closer look Progressives and State Farms mobile apps:
Progressive
- App Store : Progressives iOS mobile app carries a high average rating. iPhone users can download this free app and get access to their ID cards, request roadside assistance, start a new insurance claim and pay their monthly premium.
- : Progressives Android mobile app offers all of the same features as the iOS app, but this one has slightly better ratings. You can get roadside assistance, pay your premiums, report a claim and more right from your phone.
State Farm
Does Progressive Offer A Diminishing Deductible
Yes, Progressive has a diminishing deductible option. Also known as a vanishing deductible or disappearing deductible, this type of optional coverage reduces a policyâs deductible without increasing premiums if you are accident-free or ticket-free.
The deductible decreases when the policy is renewed and has the potential of reaching $0. Progressive offers diminishing deductibles on insurance for cars, RVs, motorcycles and boats.
Progressiveâs Deductible Savings Bank Coverage subtracts $50 from comprehensive and collision deductible for each six months that you donât cause an accident or get a ticket. A driver in this program could get $100 shaved off a deductible in a year. A person with a $500 deductible may wind up not having any deductible after five years of good driving.
Recommended Reading: All Clear Travel Insurance Reviews
Allstate Vs State Farm: Customer Satisfaction
As part of our provider comparison, we looked at online reviews from current and past policyholders from both Allstate and State Farm. Overall, both companies have mostly positive reviews, with customers citing efficient claim handling, prompt roadside assistance, affordable premiums, and useful mobile tools.
Most of the negative reviews for Allstate and State Farm are from customers who feel they didnt receive a fair payout after a claim or had a claim denied. Other customers said they have struggled to get in touch with agents and had issues with billing.
It is important to note that State Farm and Allstate work with independent agents, which means you have to call your personal agent to manage your policy and ask questions about your coverage. Your agent is able to provide the best customer service, but because they work with many policyholders, it could be more difficult to get in touch with them.
Rates By Credit Score
Drivers with bad credit typically pay higher car insurance premiums, unless you live in California, Hawaii, Massachusetts or Michigan, where credit-based insurance scores are not allowed to be used as a factor for determining your auto insurance rates. Washington state is also currently voting on a measure that would ban credit as a rating factor. For drivers with poor, average and excellent credit, rates may be affected, depending on whether or not the insurer factors in credit when determining your rates.
When providers use credit to help determine a driver’s risk factor, it is referred to as the driver’s insurance score. Generally, drivers with lower credit scores are deemed more likely to file claims. The table below showcases the national average premiums for drivers in different credit tiers.
| $1,487 |
You May Like: Guaranteed Acceptance Life Insurance No Waiting Period
Special Services And Discounts
Every auto insurance company offers standard coverages such as liability, comprehensive and collision, but each company also offers their own special services and discounts to their customers. Be sure to look into the various special options that are offered so you can potentially save money or gain more coverage for your vehicle.
Progressive Insurance offers a snapshot tool which tracks your driving habits and uses them to potentially offer you a lower rate when you renew your policy. The driver training discount from State Farm Insurance offers savings when any driver under the age of 21 has completed a qualifying drivers education course.
Most auto insurance companies offer safe driver discounts that lower the cost of premiums for those who do not get into an accident for a certain amount of time. Many companies also offer bundled discounts for customers who buy additional policies, such as home or boat insurance. Military or public service status can also be a common factor used when applying a discount on car insurance from many companies. Customers that stay with the same insurer for many years can also get a loyalty discount for not leaving the company for so long. When shopping around for coverage, be sure to ask about these types of discounts.
Reviews Of Car Insurance Companies
Fortunately, we live in the information age and can quickly find reviews of every car insurance company out there before we buy. Looking at customer reviews can be a great way to learn more about any company before doing business with them. See what other customers have dealt with, how many people enjoyed their experience and how many did not have a happy ending to their car insurance story.
The Better Business Bureau offers a lot of useful information on many major companies throughout the United States, including car insurance companies. According to their website, AAA, State Farm, Progressive and State Auto have an A+ rating. Some organizations are not rated by the BBB, however, such as Allstate and The General insurance. This is not a failed rating, just a rating of Not Available. No matter the company rating, the Better Business Bureau is a great resource to consider when looking for information on your car insurance company choices.
Websites like Yelp also offer customer reviews and ratings for car insurance companies. Users can go on the website and explain the situation they experienced, along with details of the outcome. Take a look at the experiences of other customers and see what they have been through and consider these when making your choice. Also remember, most people will share their bad experiences more often than their good ones, so if a company looks just okay, they may be a good choice, after all.
Also Check: Citizen Insurance Company Of America
Which Is The Best Auto Insurance Company
Every driver will have a different opinion on the best auto insurance company. USAA may be the best choice for some drivers, while Progressive might be a better option for others. We recommend shopping around for insurance companies and getting multiple quotes in order to find the best deal for you.
Does Progressive Offer Usage
Yes, Progressive has a usage-based insurance program called Snapshot. You can use use a mobile app or a plug-in device to allow Snapshot to track your driving.
The Snapshot app tracks miles driven and your driving habits, including how much you accelerate and brake, when you are driving, and, in some states, if youâre using your phone. Progressive says Snapshot leads to an average savings of $146 in a year.
Your rates may actually increase if Snapshot finds that youâre a risky driver
Also Check: Home Owners Insurance In Florida
Its All About You We Want To Help You Make The Right Coverage Choices
Advertiser Disclosure: We strive to help you make confident auto insurance decisions. Comparison shopping should be easy. We are not affiliated with any one auto insurance provider and cannot guarantee quotes from any single provider. Our auto insurance industry partnerships dont influence our content. Our opinions are our own. To compare quotes from many different auto insurance companies please enter your ZIP code on this page to use the free quote tool. The more quotes you compare, the more chances to save.
Editorial Guidelines: We are a free online resource for anyone interested in learning more about auto insurance. Our goal is to be an objective, third-party resource for everything auto insurance related. We update our site regularly, and all content is reviewed by auto insurance experts.
- Progressive and State Farm are two of the top ten companies in the auto insurance industry
- State Farm has the largest market share in the auto insurance industry
- State Farm is known for cheap rates, but it carries more expensive rates for policyholders with poor credit
- Progressive has more discounts
If you want to see if you can compare Progressive vs. State Farm auto insurance quotes in your local area, enter your ZIP code in the free comparison tool above to see if these two insurance giants pop up in your area.
What Is The Overview Of State Farm Car Insurance
State Farm is a Bloomington, Illinois-based insurance provider. According to The Zebra, State Farm is the largest car insurance provider in the U.S. and has over 18,000 agents across the country, so customers can speak with a representative in most locations.
State Farm has several programs designed to provide users discounts. For example, the Drive Safe and Save program monitors your driving via your mobile device or car’s OnStar system, allowing you to qualify for up to 50% in discounts.
State Farm also provides several ways for young drivers to get discounts, including the good student discount and Steer Clear Driver program. This program rewards drivers under 25 who have had no accidents or violations in the past three years with a discount.
State Farm is also suitable for people with very poor credit. The company offers cheaper rates for drivers with less than 580 credit score than Progressive, says The Zebra.
You May Like: Usaa Insurance Claim Phone Number
Progressive Vs State Farm: Everything You Need To Know
Assessing Progressive vs. State Farm can help you determine which of these two national insurance providers to choose for your auto insurance policy. Both have a presence nationwide and offer affordable rates and generous discounts. In this article, we discuss the basics you need to know when comparing Progressive and State Farm.
Assessing Progressive vs. State Farm can help you determine which of these two national insurance providers to choose for your auto insurance policy. Both have a presence nationwide and offer affordable rates and generous discounts. In this article, we discuss the basics you need to know when comparing Progressive and State Farm.
Comparison Of Car Insurance Rates Between Progressive And State Farm
In terms of their average annual premiums, and third-party ratings, State Farm and Progressive are similar. Progressives rates are generally slightly more expensive than State Farms, according to J.D. Power and AM Best rate them slightly higher than State Farm in terms customer satisfaction and financial strength ratings, respectively. Below is a comparison of Progressives average premiums and third party ratings:
Read Also: Full Coverage Car Insurance For Cheap
Progressive Vs State Farm: Cheapest For Male Drivers
The discrepancy between these two auto insurers is negligible for auto insurance rates. At the same time, State Farm takes a slightly lower premium for male driver profiles. State Farm pays its female representatives $1272, while Progressive pays its male representatives $1347.
The disparity is primarily attributed to Progressive’s lower driver rate at $1670, relative to State Farm’s $1469. These two insurers offer relatively identical rates for the other age groups, while State Farm’s are slightly cheaper. Progressive charges the same 35-year-old male a $1274 yearly rate, while State Farm is only $1205. Progressive has an annual premium rate for 60-year-olds of $1174, over State Farm’s rate of $1098.
What Is The Overview Of Progressive Car Insurance
Progressive started operations in 1938. It is the biggest personal auto insurance provider for independent insurance agents in the U.S. The company provides a wide range of coverage levels at different price points.
Progressive serves over 18 million drivers, but it also offers homeowners and renters insurance through nonaffiliated insurers. The company also allows you to bundle your auto and homeowner insurance policies to get discounts.
Snapshot is a usage-based insurance program popular among Progressive customers, says Clearsurance. Participants in the program are eligible for a discount after six months if they use the app or an OBD plug-in to monitor their safe driving habits. However, the Snapshot program can also increase your premium if its evaluations show you are a risky driver.
Progressive auto insurance is especially attractive to drivers who work for transport network companies like Uber and Lyft. The company provides such drivers ride-share insurance to cover the difference between their personal insurance policies and that of the transport network company.
Progressive also provides another optional coverage called the deductible saving bank. Under this policy, users with collision and comprehensive insurance policies can get a $50 discount on their deductible every six months they don’t make a claim.
Don’t Miss: Does Health Insurance Cover Vasectomy
Progressives Auto Insurance Discounts
Progressive offers many discounts, especially for drivers who practice safe driving habits. If you have a teen driver, look for Progressiveâs discounts for teen drivers, good students and students away at school.
Here are Progressive auto insurance discounts you may qualify for:
Related: Cheap car insurance of 2022
Is Progressive Insurance Good
Purchasing a Progressive car insurance policy can be worth it for many drivers. The insurer has a wide selection of auto insurance policies and add-on coverage options, although Progressive insurance reviews from customers are mixed.
On average, full coverage rates from Progressive tend to be about 19% 7% cheaper than the national average for good drivers. The company also has flexible offerings such as usage-based insurance and rideshare insurance, appealing to a wide range of drivers. Here are some additional features Progressive offers that set it apart from competitors:
- Low rates for high-risk drivers: Based on our in-depth industry research, we found that Progressive offers some of the lowest premium costs on average for high-risk drivers, which includes those with a recent DUI, speeding ticket or accident on their record.
- Snapshot®program: Progressive tracks your driving habits through the app to see how safely you drive. Depending on how safe you are on the road, you may qualify for a discount.
- Discount opportunities: With Progressive, drivers can take advantage of the companys wide range of discounts, which include multi-policy and teen driver discounts.
Pros and Cons of Progressive Auto Insurance
Here are the pros and cons of purchasing a Progressive policy.
Recommended Reading: What Does An Insurance Broker Do
Big Names Vs Smaller Ones
There are tons of companies that offer car insurance, both large and small. Some of these companies are nationwide and others just offer their services to a specific region of the country. Heres a quick rundown of just a few.
AAA was founded in 1902 as a non-profit and offers vehicle insurance, trip planning, repairs, and general advice on travel. With 50 million+ members, they are one of the most highly respected insurance companies in the United States today.
State Farm was founded in 1922 and offers insurance and banking to their clients. State Farm is one of the largest in the market today, with millions of customers all around the country.
Progressive Insurance was founded in 1937 and offers all the common forms of insurance, including auto, home, and life insurance policies. Progressive was the first insurer to offer 24/7 claims support, showing that they have been known to be ahead of the curve within the industry.
These are just 3 of the largest options available for car insurance coverage. There are countless other organizations, including many regional and one-state insurance companies that offer their own mix of coverage and service.
How To Choose The Best Company For You
There are many car insurance companies competing for your business no matter where you live.
If your main deciding factor is price, get price quotes from multiple companies. Don’t rely on friends and family to recommend a good deal. That’s because the best company for you will vary based on your location, driving record, credit and other factors.
Also, if your driving record has changed over the years, the company that offered a good deal previously may no longer be cheap for you.
Also Check: How To Get Insurance To Pay For Plastic Surgery