What Determines How Much You Pay For Auto Insurance
Though virtually every state requires drivers to carry a certain minimum amount of liability coverage, drivers have a great deal of flexibility in choosing the amounts and types of coverage on their auto policies. Americans paid an average of $1,633 in 2021, with projections for 2022 estimated at $1,707. The average American pays roughly $136 per month for car insurance, according to Insurify, the insurance comparison cost website.
But that’s just an average, of course, and the price you pay could be higher or lower, depending on many different factors, such as:
How Are Insurance Rates Determined
The cost of insurance depends on various factors, most notably the type of coverage youre getting.
Minimum liability coverage is mandatory in nearly every state, but the operative word is minimum. There are many additional options to increase your safety. Calculating the insurance fee, also known as a premium, can sometimes be challenging. Companies have to draw from several data points and statistics to calculate the likelihood of a specific driver being involved in an accident.
How Can I Lower My Car Insurance Rates
If your driving record leaves something to be desired, a defensive driving course can help relieve your insurance companys concerns. Take a look at the type of coverage you have to see if you can trim your coverage limits, along with your deductible. Ask an insurance agent what you can do to earn lower rates.
Also Check: Can I Have Both Employer Insurance And Medicare
A Broken Supply Chain
Choke points in the supply chain dont directly impact insurance premiums. However, they do affect the price of new cars and replacement car parts.
It doesnt matter much which point in the supply chain you study things arent running smoothly. There are loads of reasons for this a depleted workforce from the COVID-19 pandemic, high fuel costs, and shifting demand. Plus, too much reliance on just in time inventory management, leaving many industries victim to a supply stoppage of more than a few days. Many suppliers were down for months, not days. Its been a game of catch-up ever since.
Currently, theres a shortage of truck drivers, dock workers, and freight ships.
Summary: You can at least partially blame high car prices and expensive replacement parts on a busted supply chain.
Electric Vs Ice Vehicles

If youve chosen your car with the environment in mind, you may get the added benefit of lower insurance. CompareTheMarket found that in the first quarter of 2021, electric car insurance was £45 cheaper than petrol or diesel cars.
However, a 2021 New Car Buyer survey found that less than 1% of new EV buyers were aged 24 or younger, while drivers aged 55 and older made up 54%. As the 55+ age category already has the lowest premiums, age could be a greater contributor to the low average than the vehicle. With this in mind, a young EV driver may find that their electric car premium is actually higher than ICE alternatives.
Saving tip: Electric vehicles could be a cheaper alternative for older drivers, but if youre a new or young driver, its worth checking out quotes before you commit to a car.
Recommended Reading: Fidelity & Guaranty Life Insurance Company
Is A Civic Or Accord Better
With an available hybrid powertrain, a more spacious interior, more powerful engines, and a larger trunk, the Honda Accord is the winner in this comparison over the Civic. It’s not as new as the Civic or as high-tech, but for the majority of consumers, the extra space and performance are better trade-offs.
Why Is Car Insurance So High: Everything You Need To Know
Many people don’t fully understand what affects their insurance rate or why premiums fluctuate. There are several factors that contribute to the cost of your insurance.
Have you been asking yourself “why is my car insurance so high?” without really understanding what you’re paying for and why you’re being charged the rates that you are? If so, you’re not alone. Many people don’t fully understand what affects their insurance rate or why premiums fluctuate. There are several factors that contribute to the cost of your insurance. Money Under 30 shares a few of them:
You May Like: Ocean Harbor Casualty Insurance Company
Which Of These Factors Are The Most Important
Unfortunately, age is a strong predictor of the average cost of car insurance, as is your driving history. Usually, these cant be altered without the simple passage of time. But there are always ways to lower your rates. And if youre not comparing quotes regularly, you cant be sure you have the best car insurance rates to begin with.
Why Auto Insurance Rates Are Going Up
Reasons behind rising car insurance premiums and ways to help manage them.
With prices on the rise due to inflation, auto insurance rates have also been affected. Throughout the insurance industry, vehicle insurance rates are increasing by an average of 4.9%. Here are a few reasons why auto insurance rates are going up, along with what you can do to help manage your rates.
Read Also: Security Life Of Denver Insurance Company
Federal Programs Are Drying Up
With the passing of the Affordable Care Act, the federal government provided a series of incentives to states in order to jump-start the Health Insurance Marketplace. This results in premiums that were actually undervalued, so it was only a matter of time before those began to creep up again with the elimination of such incentives.
Dating back a few years, the government was reimbursing health insurance providers for certain costs associated with enrolling high-risk individuals that were required to be insured under the provisions of Obamacare. Previously, these individuals were either denied insurance or the costs associated with their care were passed on to those individuals in the form of higher premiums.
Since health insurance providers are now required to accept everyone, the government was helping to offset some of the costs associated with that increased risk.
The past few years, however, the government has gradually begun to reduce payment amounts that they issued to health insurance companies on annual basis. At the current time, those payments have ended in their entirety, which has lead the Academy of Actuaries to estimate will increase health insurance premiums in the range of 4 to 7 percent.
Your Cars Garaging Address
This is a strange answer to Why is my car insurance so high?
Yes, the location you park your vehicle can affect your car insurance rates, according to the Insurance Information Institute. And when you look at the reasons, its not so surprising after all. A car in the calm, stable climate of northern California is far less likely to be damaged by hail than one in Kansas. If you park your car at a rural address, its far less likely to be broken into than in a city with a high crime rate.
So it stands that weather patterns, the local crime rate, and the number of claims made within the vicinity of your cars garaging address are all factored into the price of your premium. If you move into a heavily populated city instead of a spread-out suburban area, youll likely see your rates go up as a result.
Likewise, suppose you park in a place with a more unpredictable climate. In that case, you could experience a rate increase due to the risks of a hurricane, snowstorm, tornado, or other damaging weather phenomena. You can have some degree of control over this by talking with your insurance agent if you are moving to a new location. Be sure to ask how much your move will affect your overall premium cost so you can shop and budget accordingly.
Recommended Reading: Face Value Of Life Insurance
Reason: You Have Bad Credit
In most states, auto insurance companies use your credit score when calculating your car insurance premiums. Therefore, if you have a poor credit score, you may end up having to pay higher insurance premiums. However, the cost increase may depend on the auto insurance provider you choose and where you live.
According to the Insurance Information Institute, credit-based insurance scores are confidential ratings based on the insured individuals credit information. Many insurance providers use credit scores in combination with other factors to help determine premiums. This is typically the case for insurance lines such as personal car insurance.
What to Do About It: Invest in Credit Repair Services
According to actuarial studies, insured car owners with poor credit scores are a higher insurance risk. This is because they tend to file more claims. Taking the necessary steps to improve your credit score may simultaneously lower your insurance premiums as well.
Before you ask your insurance provider, Why is my car insurance so high?, keep in mind that not all insurers calculate rates in the same way. Therefore, one carrier may weigh your credit score more heavily than another. For instance, auto insurance companies based in California, Massachusetts, and Hawaii do not even consider credit scores when calculating premiums.
Heres Why Your Car Insurance Is So High

Having car insurance is required in all states except New Hampshire, which has no mandatory insurance law, and Virginia, where you can pay an annual fee to the DMV instead of purchasing insurance.
The minimum amount of insurance coverage required and the actual cost of an insurance policy varies by state.
However, even in states that traditionally have lower rates, you may still be asking yourself, Why is my car insurance so high?
If you believe your insurance is too high, you might want to do a little background research.
Insurance providers calculate insurance premiums based on risk.
While your geographic location is a key factor, there are numerous other elements they use to determine the overall risk of insuring you.
This guide explains how each one affects your car insurance premium, providing valuable insight into how you can then lower your costs.
You May Like: Car And Home Insurance Quote
Reason: Where You Live
Car insurance costs vary widely across the United States. If you reside in Michigan, one of the most expensive states for auto insurance, you can expect to pay several times more than people living in Maine.
Various factors affect insurance rates in each state. These include the number of uninsured drivers, condition of the road network, minimum coverage amounts, and more. That said, you need to understand that insurance rates can vary within a state or city as well.
For example, if you live in an area with narrow roads that frequently lead to accidents, you may have to pay more for insurance than you would if you lived elsewhere. Those who live in areas with high rates of auto thefts tend to pay more for car insurance as well.
What to Do About It: Move
Moving to a new neighborhood, city, or state just to pay lower insurance premiums may not be the smartest move. However, if you are already considering relocating, you should get several quotes from insurance providers to understand how your premiums will differ.
Shopping Outside Of State/federal Marketplaces
If you find yourself falling off the subsidy cliff , youre probably going to benefit from a private marketplace like eHealth. On our online marketplace, we offer ACA plans along with many other alternatives that youll likely find are more affordable. Keep in mind, a more affordable health insurance plan will likely mean less benefits are covered, but being covered by a plan with less benefits is probably a better option than not being able to afford health insurance at all. Whether its due to the subsidy cliff, or something else, many middle-income individuals and families are shopping outside of government exchanges to find their insurance.Private exchanges such as eHealth offer a wider selection of health insurance plans than government exchanges. Some people may find they can save money by buying an off-market plan through a private exchange.It takes as little as providing your zip code to get quotes on all different kinds of plans at eHealth. Youll find that its incredibly easy to compare prices for plans with eHealth, in order to find something that is right for your health care needs and budge
Also Check: 10 Top Life Insurance Companies
The Kind Of Car You Drive
That new Porsche or Tesla might be fun to drive, but theyre sending up your insurance rate. Even if you dont have a sports or luxury car, expensive vehicles or cars with expensive parts cost more to insure.
Vehicle safety can also affect your insurance prices. Cars that do well on safety tests, like the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety test, have lower insurance premiums.
Look up the safety ratings the next time youre shopping for a new car, or ask your insurance agent how it might affect your rate.
Why Is My Insurance So High How To Cut Costs
When the national average for auto insurance is $1,621 a year, finding savings every way you can give your budget some breathing room. But theres not much you can do about your insurance premiums, right?
Wrong.
There are lots of ways to cut the costs of your auto insurance premiums. In fact, there are things you can do today that will add up to real savings.
To help you stop asking the question, Why is my car insurance so high?, lets look at ways to save you money.
Read Also: What Disqualifies From Long-term Care Insurance
Your Car Insurance Coverage Options
The more car insurance you buy, the more you can expect to pay. A full coverage policy, which includes comprehensive and collision insurance, costs 170% more in annual premiums than one with liability coverage only. Comprehensive and collision insurance cover the cost to repair or replace your vehicle if it is damaged, less your deductible â which is the amount you have to pay out of pocket before your coverage kicks in.
Policies that include high liability limits as well as comprehensive and collision coverage with low deductibles are particularly expensive. The cost of a policy such as this is $1,053 more per year compared to the cost of a liability-only policy.
How to save: You have total control over the coverage on your policy, so you can easily reduce your limits â so long as you’re above the legal limit and meet any requirements your lender has. But if you’re in an accident, you’ll be responsible for any claim that goes over your insurance limits.
Are There Any Other Reasons Why The Cost Of Car Insurance Is So High In 2022
There are a number of reasons conspiring to keep car insurance costs high:
- A cut to the Ogden rate, which determines compensation payments, from 2.5% to 0.25% has increased payouts for victims, but also increased car insurance costs as a result.
- Claims are becoming more expensive with a rise in keyless car crime.
- Uninsured drivers – according to the Motor Insurance Bureau they add £30 to every car insurance cost.
Read Also: Blue Cross Blue Shield Dental Insurance
Practice Good Driving Habits
Although it varies by state, just one speeding ticket can drive up your rate by $367 per year. Practicing good driving habits and having a clear driving record is probably the most simple and self-explanatory way to improve your insurance premium. If you have gotten several speeding tickets and had an accident or two, you have probably already seen your rate increase or expect a higher premium at your next renewal.
Some states offer defensive driver courses that can limit the number of points against your license and if the course is approved by your insurance company, you may be able to lower your premium. Additionally, some companies offer accident forgiveness plans that would keep your auto insurance from going up in the event of one accident.
Youve Been Bouncing Around Insurance Companies

Chasing down cheaper home insurance policies will help you, but only to a point. If youve been jumping from insurance provider to insurance provider on an annual basis, you could be saving money every year, but losing in the long term.
How to lower your costs: Stick with an agency for discounts.
If you stay with an insurance company for five years or more, you could be eligible for a loyalty discount. Loyalty discounts are typically around 5%, says Royster, and homeowners can ask for them after a few years of continuous claims-free coverage.
Read Also: Auto Insurance Quotes Online Comparison
Factors That Determine How Much You Pay For Car Insurance
Virtually every state across the U.S. requires drivers to have a certain level of liability coverage. However, as a car owner, you have a great deal of flexibility in choosing the type and amount of coverage on your policy.
According to a recent analysis by Bankrate.com, car owners in America paid an average of about $1,674 per year for full coverage auto insurance. This figure included liability, collision, comprehensive, and underinsured or uninsured motorist coverage. However, this amount is just the average. Your rate could be lower or higher, depending on various factors.
Why is my car insurance so high? This is a question that most car owners ask themselves at one time or another. This is because your auto insurance premiums are often a variable expense. Car insurance can also account for up to 2.4% of your yearly income.
Are you looking for ways to spend less on car insurance? If so, you need to understand the factors that affect your insurance premiums. For instance, you cannot control variables such as the frequency of claims based on geographic location. However, you can control components such as your driving record, insurance history, and the type of car you own.
Fortunately, you can take certain steps to lower your rates. Some of the reasons why your car insurance is high include the following: